In December, protesters at Cloverdale Fairgrounds show their support for farmers in India. Hundreds gathered at the fairgrounds before driving in a convoy to the Indian consulate in Vancouver to protest three new laws they say will negatively impact farmers in India. (File photo: Jason Sveinson)

In December, protesters at Cloverdale Fairgrounds show their support for farmers in India. Hundreds gathered at the fairgrounds before driving in a convoy to the Indian consulate in Vancouver to protest three new laws they say will negatively impact farmers in India. (File photo: Jason Sveinson)


GUEST COLUMN: Why Canadians should care about India’s farm bills

The protests are resisting a breakdown of constitutional democracy and a shift towards fascism

By Harjote Sumbal

By now, news of the farmer-labourer protest in India has made its way through global news cycles, with many dubbing it the largest protest in human history.

The Trudeau administration publicly addressed concerns about the treatment of peaceful protesters, much to the ire of the Indian government. Some Canadians have also expressed annoyance at Trudeau’s comments, while others have grown impatient of local rallies of solidarity. The sustained effort of protesters and supporters around the world coupled with the diminishing Canadian media coverage of the events begs the question: Why should Canadians care about the protest?

The answer, simply put, is that the protests are currently resisting a breakdown of constitutional democracy and a shift towards fascism. Both Canada and India largely operate as types of constitutional democracies modelled on British legislative supremacy. While there are some differences between the two, India and Canada feature similar governmental structures including federalism, human rights and freedoms, and constitutionality. However, India is currently disregarding these structures in an authoritarian crackdown on peaceful protesters, and is relying on the silence of states like Canada to construe it as acceptable.

(Story continues below photo)


PICTURED: Guest columnist Harjote Sumbal. (submitted photo)

• RELATED NEWS STORY, from December: Trudeau brushes off India’s criticism for standing with farmers in anti-Modi protests.

• READ ALSO: Angry farmers storm India’s Red Fort in challenge to Modi.

A preliminary consideration of a legal dispute is often the question of jurisdiction. For example, within Canada, sections 91 and 92 of the Constitution designate provincial and federal governments the power to enact laws concerning various areas of public life. Similarly in India, territorial jurisdictions concerning the States and the Union (the federal government) are set out in Schedule VII of the Indian Constitution. In India, agriculture is the subject of Article 14 of the State List and falls exclusively within the jurisdiction of states, and for good reason. Conservative estimates report Punjab alone produces approximately a third of India’s wheat and 12 per cent of its rice, despite covering 1.5 per cent of the physical territory and holding only 13 of 543 seats in the federal legislature.

Canadians are often also embroiled in jurisdictional struggles of purported federal overreach (think Alberta oil or protecting French in Quebec). In B.C., the housing crisis and automobile insurance are often hot-button topics of a local nature. There would be strong, legitimate concerns if the federal government attempted to dictate ICBC (a provincial Crown corporation) rates or implement rent-pricing floors or caps. In India, the federal government has cast aside the Schedule VII lists and dictated the decimation of agricultural infrastructure at the cost of the stability and wellbeing of millions of farmers and labourers.

Another core component of our Constitution is the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms. Within it are enshrined fundamental freedoms, democratic, mobility rights, legal and equality rights. The purpose of the Charter ensures an elected majority does not result in an oppressive government that infringes on the minority’s rights. Part III of the Constitution of India also lays out fundamental rights, with Article 19 specifically providing for the freedom of speech, the right to assemble peacefully, and the right to move freely throughout India.

With the federal legislature hastily passing the bills in a special session amid the pandemic, farmers across India have faced baton charges, tear gas, water cannons, barricades, and sabotaged highway routes over the last year in their effort to open dialogue with the government. On Jan. 26, when farmers conducted a tractor parade in Delhi after sleeping on highways for two months, they were again subject to batons and tear gas. As protesters were injured and at least one died, Prime Minister Modi oversaw an extravagant Republic Day parade a few kilometres away.

(Column continues below)

So how should Canadians respond to the local support of farmers protest? Canadians should be thankful to those participating in the protest for reminding us what an active democracy looks like. While media coverage fluctuates (see Rihanna’s Feb. 2 Twitter trend), we should actively support those fighting for human rights and holding power accountable, especially since mere participation makes a difference. Protesters in India have exhausted all other avenues available to them whether they are political, legal, or appeals to empathy and humanity.

Constitutionality in Canada, India, or anywhere else is not self-evident; it must be upheld by combatting injustice. The world is inextricably bound by economic, political, and environmental ties and every action, or inaction for that matter, has tangible ramifications. India has engaged in misinformation campaigns, the abduction and assault of journalists and protesters, and has erected permanent guarded barricades across highways to halt free movement. All of this is occurring under government-imposed Internet and electricity blackouts, hoping the international community remains unaware and silent.

As Desmond Tutu stated, “If you are neutral in situations of injustice, you have chosen the side of the oppressor.” With each passing assault on its people, India chooses fascism. It is time for all Canadians to choose a side.

Harjote Sumbal, a Surrey resident, is a second-year law student at Thompson Rivers University.

• RELATED NEWS STORY: ‘It won’t end’: Protesters march for Indian farmers at another Surrey rally, with more to come.

Get local stories you won't find anywhere else right to your inbox.
Sign up here

Just Posted

Sports broadcaster and 30-year high school football coach Farhan Lalji. (Image via
Farhan Lalji chats about the new B.C. high school sports governance proposal

Lalji, a 30-year high school football coach, thinks the new proposal will be bad for student athletes

Surrey city Councillor Brenda Locke. (File photo)
Surrey councillor trying to get policing referendum on the table, again

‘I’m sending it back for clarification,’ mayor decides

A simulation lab at Surrey Memorial Hospital has been helping healthcare professionals train during the COVID-19 pandemic. (Submitted photo)
Surrey Memorial Hospital’s simulation lab trains professionals during COVID-19 pandemic

Surrey Hospitals Foundation contributing $100K toward new technologies

Dr. Bonnie Henry speaks about the province’s COVID-19 vaccine plans during a news conference at the legislature in Victoria. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Chad Hipolito
Dr. Bonnie Henry says Surrey immunization targeted at neighbourhoods most at risk

‘What we’ve been looking at is the case rates by neighbourhood,’ provincial health officer says

A horse and driver cruise around the track at Fraser Downs in Cloverdale Sept. 14, 2020 amid smoke from U.S. forest fires. Harness Racing B.C. announced it’s halting the spring season two weeks early because of a lack of money and says racing won’t continue in September without and influx of cash. (Photo: Malin Jordan)
Harness racing suspended at Fraser Downs

Spring season ends early, 135 workers out of jobs

Rainbow trouts thrashing with life as they’re about to be transferred to the largest lake of their lives, even though it’s pretty small. These rainbows have a blue tinge because they matched the blue of their hatchery pen, but soon they’ll take on the green-browns of their new home at Lookout Lake. (Zoe Ducklow/News Staff)
VIDEO: B.C. lake stocked with hatchery trout to delight of a seniors fishing club

The Cherish Trout Scouts made plans to come back fishing soon

Royal Inland Hospital in Kamloops. (Dave Eagles/Kamloops This Week file photo)
RCMP intercept vehicle fleeing with infant taken from Kamloops hospital

The baby was at the hospital receiving life-saving care

The female driver of this Jeep Grand Cherokee (right) was driving erratically with a young child inside on Highway 1 eastbound. After hitting a barrier and a parked car, she finally exited the highway at Yale Road West and came to a stop. (Jenna Hauck/ Chilliwack Progress)
Video captures woman driving erratically with child after hitting barrier, car on Hwy 1 in Chilliwack

Smoke seen coming from SUV as it continues to travel eastbound of shoulder of highway

Former Pitt Meadows city councillor David Murray was convicted of sex assault, and is now being sued by the victim. (files)
Former Pitt Meadows city councillor sued for sex assault

David Murray was convicted in 2017 of sexually assaulting a teen 25 years earlier

Vancouver Police Const. Deepak Sood is under review by the Independent Investigations Office of B.C. after making comments to a harm reduction advocate Sunday, April 11. (Screen grab)
VIDEO: Vancouver officer convicted of uttering threats under watchdog review again

Const. Deepak Sood was recorded Sunday saying ‘I’ll smack you’ and ‘go back to selling drugs’ to a harm reduction advocate

Provincial health officer Dr. Bonnie Henry prepares a daily update on the coronavirus pandemic, April 21, 2020. (B.C. Government)
B.C.’s COVID-19 infection rate persists, 1,005 new cases Friday

Hospitalization up to 425, six more virus-related deaths

The Nautical Dog Cafe at Skaha marina is getting its patio ready in hopes Mother Nature will provide where provincial restrictions have taken away indoor dining. (Facebook)
‘A lot of instability’: B.C. restaurants in layoff limbo

As COVID-19 cases stay high, restaurants in British Columbia are closed to indoor dining

Prime Minister Justin Trudeau looks on as Deputy Prime Minister and Finance Minister Chrystia Freeland responds to a question during a news conference on Parliament Hill in Ottawa, Tuesday, Aug. 18, 2020. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Adrian Wyld
Expectations high as Trudeau Liberals get ready to unveil first pandemic budget

The Liberals will look to thread an economic needle with Monday’s budget

Since April 4, 38 flights with COVID-19 cases have departed from Vancouver International Airport, while 23 arrived. (Phil McLachlan/Capital News)
Vancouver the largest source of domestic flights with COVID-19 cases: data

This month alone, 38 flights with COVID-19 cases have departed from Vancouver International Airport, while 23 arrived

Most Read