A stop worker order will remain in place at a development at 5904 144 St. until the City of Surrey and Department of Fisheries and Oceans sign off on a remediation plan for the site.

$175,000 penalty for Surrey tree cut

Developer must remedy damage, is being fined $25K, and is ordered to provide a $150K security deposit.

A local developer is fuming after being slapped with fines and a damage deposit totalling more than $175,000 for cutting down trees in Newton in August.

Paul Bal said the issue has been blown out of proportion in the media, and said if there was damage, it was caused by his subcontractor, JB Demolition.

The city said neither Bal or JB Demolition is accepting blame for the cut, which Surrey General Manager of Planning and Development Jean Lamontagne said went beyond city permits and into protected parkland areas and other private lands.

City staff also said JB Demolition doesn’t have a Surrey business licence, which would be required to do the tree-cutting work.

In August, the city gave permission for Bal to cut down 39 trees on his property at 5904 144 St. to make room for two residential lots. When JB Demolition arrived, those trees were cut down, along with several others in a park, along a riverbed, and on two private properties.

City staff allege that the heavy equipment was delivered to the west side of the property and was driven over a tributary of Hyland Creek to work on the east portion of the land.

Damage to the creek bed caught the immediate attention of the Department of Fisheries and Oceans (DFO), which launched an investigation. So did the City of Surrey.

Don Luymas, Surrey’s manager of community planning, said it’s not clear who was at fault for the cut, but added for the city’s purposes, it doesn’t matter.

The developer, who is in charge of the project, must take ultimate responsibility for his subtrades, Luymas said.

Bal insists the tree cut was not his fault.

He said the media blew the issue out of proportion, adding he will take a huge financial hit for the mistake.

“I’ve already spent over 10 grand to hire an arbourist and environmentalist and all that,” Bal said, estimating the remedial work in the park land will run into tens of thousands of dollars.

“It’s going to be costly,” Bal said.

In all, the total bill for Bal will be more than $175,000.

The bulk of that (about $150,000) is a security deposit to ensure restoration work in the park is still viable in three years, and the city says a $25,400 fine is for what it believes were 14 trees protected by Surrey’s bylaw taken down on private properties.

Bal said there were only nine trees that came down without permits.

He noted not even the profits from the development are likely to cover the cost of fines and deposits.

“I don’t think so, not at all, zero,” Bal said.

If Bal believes his subcontractor is responsible for the damage, he can seek remedies through legal action.

“If I have no choice, I will,” Bal said. He’s not sure the subcontractor has the financial means to cover the bill.

Bal’s remediation plan has yet to be reviewed and accepted by both the City of Surrey and the DFO.

A stop work order will remain on the property until the city and DFO sign off on the plan.

kdiakiw@surreyleader.com

Surrey North Delta Leader

Get local stories you won't find anywhere else right to your inbox.
Sign up here

Just Posted

Suspect in Surrey forcible confinement arrested in Toronto

Constable Richard Wright, of the Surrey RCMP, said William Daniels-Sey was arrested on Feb. 16

Outdoor AED unit in Surrey among the first in B.C.

SaveStation cabinet is alarmed and monitored – and hasn’t been used yet

ZYTARUK: Trudeau needs to stop dithering and fix blockade crisis

Trudeau noted Canadians are asking themselves, “What is happening in this country?” He’s got that right

Tamanawis boys repeat as B.C. high school wrestling champs

Sehijvir Sandhu and Karanpreet Gill earn gold medals for the Surrey team

OUR VIEW: Be vigilant when looking for love

Surrey Mounties say they’re seeing increase in sexual assault complaints related to people meeting after using online dating apps

2020 Budget: ICBC deficit will turn into $86M surplus, NDP say

ICBC operating with $91-million deficit for 2019-2020 fiscal year

Two law enforcement trucks ‘deliberately’ set on fire in northern B.C., RCMP say

Police say they have video evidence of a person in the area of the truck fires

Metro Vancouver wants the region to repurpose, donate, or repair used clothing

Textile mending workshops to be held across the Lower Mainland

UPDATE: Three protesters arrested after blocking driveway at Premier John Horgan’s Langford home

Protestors claimed they would make a citizen’s arrest of the Premier, according to West Shore RCMP

Budget 2020: B.C. adds tax to sweet drinks and sodas

All soda, vending machine drinks will be subject to higher PST

Budget 2020: B.C. unveils new grant for students, phases out debt-relief program

For the first time, diploma, certificate students qualify for yearly post-secondary grant

Budget 2020: B.C. NDP taps top tax bracket for more revenue

Minimum wage set to pass $15 an hour by 2021

Budget 2020: Not much new for B.C.’s struggling forest industry

Focus on wood waste utilization, efficiency, Carole James says

Most Read