Cartoon by Ingrid Rice.

BUCHOLTZ: Libel lawsuit a reminder of Surrey’s past

Column by Frank Bucholtz

Bruce Ralston, the longtime Surrey-Whalley MLA who is minister of jobs, trade and technology in the new NDP government, is facing a lawsuit for defamation from former BC Liberal leader/NDP cabinet minister Gordon Wilson.

Wilson was fired from his job as the provincial LNG advocate on Aug. 1, something a new government has every right to do. However, Ralston, Premier John Horgan and NDP MP Rachel Blaney all stated afterwards that he did little or nothing to earn his $150,000 annual salary. Ralston said: “It’s very difficult to see that he accomplished anything other than to cash his cheques,” while Horgan said Wilson produced “no briefings, no reports, no memoranda.” Blaney, the MP representing Wilson’s hometown of Powell River, piled on.

Unfortunately for them, a provincial government website shows that Wilson had filed 180 pages of reports, memos and updates during his first 15 months on the job.

All three have apologized, but Wilson maintains the damage to his reputation. In a statement of claim filed on Aug.17, he is asking for $5 million.

Ralston, who served on Surrey council during the 1980s and 1990s, is a longtime lawyer who is familiar with defamation lawsuits. In fact, he initiated one against a fellow councillor.

Ralston was a member of the Surrey Civic Electors slate, which held four seats after the 1987 civic election.

SCE was an arm of the provincial New Democrats, and other councillors – including some with NDP memberships – were unhappy the provincial party was playing such a direct role in municipal politics. Current Coun. Judy Villeneuve, now a member of the Surrey First slate which holds all nine council seats, was first elected as an SCE councillor.

One of those was longtime councillor Bill Fomich, an advocate for unions and working people. The lawsuit arose out of remarks Fomich made at a council meeting about Ralston. In a heated exchange over a land-use proposal, Fomich called him a “sick son of a bitch.” Fomich apologized, but he then repeated the remarks to reporters.

The case eventually wound up in B.C. Supreme Court.

In a 1992 judgment, Justice J.E. Spencer decided the words “son of a bitch” are not defamatory, that by themselves they “are not capable of defamatory meaning. They are peculiar, in that they take their meaning either from the tone of voice used or from whatever adjective accompanies them. They are a translucent vessel waiting to be filled with colour by their immediate qualifier.”

The qualifier in this case was “sick,” and that word was a problem, Spencer ruled. He wrote “the statement of claim relies upon (the word sick’s) ordinary meanings, that the plaintiff was either mentally ill, unstable or unbalanced, that he was perverted, unwholesome or morally corrupt, or that he was unfit to hold public office or to practise his profession.”

Spencer decided that by repeating that word after a council meeting, Fomich had defamed Ralston – “pouring a libelous colour into the empty words ‘son of a bitch.’”

The eventual judgment gave Ralston a modest sum, which he donated to charity.

It will be interesting to see how far the Wilson lawsuit proceeds.

Frank Bucholtz writes Fridays for the Now-Leader and he can be reached by email at frank.bucholtz@gmail.com

Get local stories you won't find anywhere else right to your inbox.
Sign up here

Just Posted

Love flourishes at Peace Arch Park, but COVID-19 concerns loom

South Surrey park becomes only place for international couples to meet

Human Rights Tribunal denies church’s request to toss out White Rock Pride Society’s complaint

Star of the Sea and White Rock Pride Society to go to Human Rights Tribunal hearing

Surrey RCMP searching for missing 12-year-old boy

Landon Vangeel-Morgan was last seen 9:14 p.m., May 30 near 96 Avenue and 150 Street

COVID-19: Daily update on pandemic in Surrey, White Rock and beyond

Provincial Health Officer officially bans overnight kids’ camps this summer

Surrey RCMP look for missing man

Tyler Ridout, 36, last seen near Balsam Crescent and 136th Street

VIDEO: Injured bald eagle rescued in B.C. First Nations community

Bird suspected injured in fight, whisked off to Coquitlam rehab

Facing changes together: Your community, your journalists

We’re asking you to lock arms with us, as we look to better days ahead

Toronto Raptors’ Ujiri says conversations about racism can no longer be avoided

Thousands have protested Floyd’s death and repeated police killings of black men across the United States

B.C.’s Central Kootenay region declares state of emergency, issues evacuation orders

The evacuation alert covers all areas except the Cities of Castelgar and Nelson

‘I’m afraid’: Witnesses of wolf attack on senior near Prince Rupert worried about safety

Frank Russ shows where the unprovoked wolf attacked his father

Protesters prepare to rally against racism in front of Vancouver Art Gallery

Rally is in response to the deaths of black Americans and a Toronto woman

Protesters rally against anti-black, Indigenous racism in Toronto

Police estimated the crowd to be between 3,500 and 4,000 and said there was no violence

Feds earmark $1.5M to support recovery of B.C., Indigenous tourism

B.C. money will be split between Vancouver Island and Indigenous tourism

‘We’re sick of it’: Anger over police killings shatters U.S.

Tens of thousands marched to protest the death of George Floyd

Most Read