Column

BUCHOLTZ: Path to Surrey LRT a lesson for future leaders

No further lines should be planned without vigorous discussion that fully involves public

Not surprisingly, Surrey’s LRT vision has become one of the election’s hottest issues. (Now-Leader file)

Nominations for local councils and boards of education close Friday (Sept. 14).

Already, candidates for Surrey council are offering diverging perspectives on the merits of LRT versus SkyTrain.

Outgoing Mayor Linda Hepner hosted the prime minister and premier last week, as they again announced the Surrey-Newton-Guildford LRT project going ahead.

Construction is to begin in 2020, with the line operational by 2024 – six years later than then-candidate Hepner promised in 2014.

The 10.5-kilometre LRT line will now cost a total of $1.65 billion.

While Hepner’s successor as Surrey First candidate for mayor, Tom Gill, is an unabashed believer that LRT is the only rapid-transit system Surrey needs, it seems few outside his slate share that enthusiasm. The public seems to be generally negative, with notable exceptions mostly from the business community.

Concerns are numerous, but one of the most-repeated is that trains and vehicle traffic cannot coexist on congested streets.

One of the points made by those who oppose trains on streets is that LRT won’t be able to operate when there is a major crash.

On Saturday, 100th Avenue was closed between 144th and 148th Streets for more than eight hours due to a fatal collision.

How long will LRT service be suspended when there is a similar crash on 104th Avenue or King George Boulevard?

Gill’s challengers for mayor are skeptical about LRT being the only solution.

Bruce Hayne, a former Surrey First slate member and incumbent councillor now running for mayor with Integrity Now, says the LRT project is too far advanced along the Guildford-Newton corridor to stop.

However, he also says SkyTrain might make more sense for the longer portion between King George Station and Langley City.

The Proudly Surrey slate, which has Pauline Greaves as its mayoral candidate, supports going ahead with LRT for the first phase but wants more discussion on future options.

Former mayor Doug McCallum, with the Safe Surrey Coalition slate, says LRT will not go ahead if he is in control.

Independent mayoral candidate Imtiaz Popat does not support either LRT or SkyTrain, calling for restoration of interurban service on the former BC Electric interurban line. People First Surrey mayoral candidate Rajesh Jayaprakash opposes LRT and wants SkyTrain instead.

The LRT project has been slow to come to fruition, largely because there was no committed funding. The defeated 2015 referendum on imposing an additional sales tax to pay for transit projects played a big part in that.

A great deal of planning and engineering has already taken place. To stop the project completely would be a waste of tax dollars.

Nonetheless, critics’ traffic concerns are valid, and every possible mitigation factor must be employed when it begins operating.

However, no further LRT lines should be planned until there is a vigorous discussion, facilitated by Surrey council and fully involving the public. Hopefully, the new council will be more open to public engagement and will actually listen to public input.

Frank Bucholtz writes weekly for the Now-Leader. You can email him at frank.bucholtz@gmail.com.



edit@surreynowleader.com

Like us on Facebook Follow us on Instagram and follow us on Twitter

Other election news:

See also: Two-person ‘Progressive Sustainable Surrey’ slate joins election race

See also: New ‘Act NOW Surrey’ slate joins school board election race

See also: Cloverdale realtor Becky Zhou to run for Surrey council

See also: John Wolanski to run for Surrey mayor

See also: Surrey First promising free access to pools, rinks and gyms for Surrey youth

See also: Proudly Surrey says asbestos needs to be removed from all schools, now

See also: EXCLUSIVE: Why we left Surrey First

See also: VIDEO: Surrey First announces full slate of candidates

See also: Mayoral candidate Pauline Greaves joins Proudly Surrey slate

See also: Parshotam Goel joins Proudly Surrey slate

See also: Steven Pettigrew and Jack Hundial join McCallum’s Safe Surrey slate

See also: Proudly Surrey announces fourth school board candidate

See also: People First Surrey announces mayoral candidate, third council hopeful

See also: Brenda Locke, Mandeep Nagra join McCallum’s Safe Surrey Coalition

See also: BUCHOLTZ: Surrey First naysayer goes out with a bang

See also: Woods joins Hayne’s Integrity Now slate as Surrey council candidate

See also: Handgun ban issue fires up Surrey candidates

See also: Surrey Honeybee Centre founder to run for council with Integrity Now

See also: Councillor Dave Woods resigns from Surrey First

See also: New independent school board candidate in Surrey

See also: Dr. Allison Patton joins Safe Surrey Coalition slate

See also: Downtown Surrey BIA announces all-candidates meetings

See also: Retired teacher Julia Poole to run for Surrey school board

See also: Pauline Greaves joins mayoral race in Surrey

See also: Avi Dhaliwal joins Surrey Integrity Now as council candidate

See also: Proudly Surrey wants to build a Rita Johnston statue, rename the Pattullo to Bob Bose Bridge

See also: McCallum keeps ‘Safe Surrey Coalition’ name, announces new candidate

See also: Rina Gill joins Bruce Hayne’s ‘Surrey Integrity Now’ party

See also: Doug Elford resigns from his Surrey party to run with McCallum

See also: People First Surrey announces first two candidates

See also: Doug McCallum running for Surrey mayor

See also: Former Surrey First Councillor Bruce Hayne to run for mayor

See also: Tom Gill is Surrey First’s mayoral candidate

See also: Hayne splits from Surrey First: ‘It’s just not open and transparent the way I’d like it to be’

See also: Surrey First’s Mary Martin not seeking re-election this fall

See also: Surrey First Councillor Judy Villeneuve not seeking re-election this fall

See more: New civic slate Proudly Surrey aims to offer ‘sharp, strong, left-leaning’ candidates

See more: Proudly Surrey introduces two more candidates for Surrey council, schoolboard

See more: Surrey Community Alliance announces intention to challenge Surrey First in civic election

See more: Surrey Community Alliance unveils civic slate, but no mayoral candidate

See more: People First Surrey party reveals intention to run in upcoming civic election

See more: Five Surrey First councillors now reveal interest in mayor’s chair

See more: With Surrey Mayor Linda Hepner out, who is mulling a mayoral run?

See more: Hawthorne Park crusader to run for Surrey council

Just Posted

Man still in hospital after struck by car in Surrey last week

The man was airlifted to hospital with “potential life-threatening” injuries after the incident

South Surrey boy’s birthday wish raises more than $3,000 for rescued farm animals

Matthew Farden had hoped to raise $1,000 for Aldergrove sanctuary

More ‘Messiah’ in Surrey: City’s new orchestra twice performs Handel’s classic

First Fleetwood Christian Reformed Church, then the Bell theatre with Vancouver Bach Choir

Surrey, Santa Claus is coming to town with lighted trucks

Special events in Cloverdale and Surrey Civic Plaza on Dec. 2

White Rock pier light show

Dancing lights highlighted off the water front

Curlers’ kicked out of Alberta bonspiel for being too drunk

‘You don’t kick around other players’ bags, it’s disrespectful and we expect better of our players’

Homicide victim found under B.C. bridge identified as Hells Angels member

Chad John Wilson was one of four men arrested in Spain in 2013 on allegations of smuggling cocaine.

B.C. Sikh temple vandalized with racist graffiti

Racist graffiti was found on the side of the building this morning

Shots fired near Chicago hospital, multiple victims: police

Police say at least one possible offender has been shot

B.C. to allow ride hailing services to operate in 2019

Fee will be applied to fund options for disabled people

Burnaby woman’s car crash death now considered a homicide

Nicole Hasselmann, 34, was killed and a man was sent to hospital after the crash

Chocolate lab missing along Coquihalla

Brad Gibson is asking for help locating his missing dog.

B.C. connection to launch of new $10 bill

Great nephew of Viola Desmond says bill is a ‘step in the right direction’

Most Read