COLUMN: Revitalizing universities through debate

We must realize that at the very core of education is the concept of questioning the status quo.

The purpose of higher education is to create critical thinkers. However, a continued emphasis on “surface-level learning” hinders innovative discussion.

The one-way teaching model prevents students from developing original thought, and instead perpetuates a system of groupthink and passive learning. It is no wonder then that students are adopting an attitude of general apathy towards the traditional lecture model, and are instead seeking a multifaceted dialogue on world issues through other means.

Lack of student participation is often the complaint of educators. To address these pressing issues, I propose a model for all universities that focuses on debate and discussion.

For centuries, universities have represented a beacon of light in our society. They symbolize the coming together of curious individuals hungry for knowledge. The Renaissance, one of the most innovative eras of human progress, was represented by the convergence of different viewpoints and ideas.

We must realize that at the very core of education is the concept of questioning the status quo. Individuals, like Galileo, were courageous to challenge conventional thought, even in the face of persecution. If universities are to instill the seed of critical analysis, they must start at the lecture hall. Encouraging debate is going to help create the next generation of innovative entrepreneurs, scientists, and policy makers.

In a book released in 2011 by Richard Arum and Josipa Roksa, which cites studies on undergraduate students, the authors find that “45 per cent of students ‘did not demonstrate any significant improvement in learning’ during the first two years of college.” Thirty-six per cent show a similar trend even after four years of college. Critical thinking is vital if we are to reverse such trends.

As a student, I have excelled in classes that rarely encourage even a single discussion throughout the semester, and others that encourage lively debates on a regular basis. Not surprisingly, the most enriching classes have been the ones in which the teacher encourages students to come out of their shell and become active participants in the learning process.

It was during the past semester that I had the chance to be enrolled in a specific political science class, at SFU Surrey, in which the professor, upon a student’s suggestion, decided to designate a portion of class time for debate amongst students. At times, the debates became heated, however, they also encouraged students to engage in dialogue and bring their external knowledge to the classroom.

Such conversations encourage a student to cognitively categorize different topics to support a viewpoint and dissect its meaning. Furthermore, such classes are more effective in teaching students creative and critical thinking.  The professor is able to guide the trajectory of the discussion and can summarize the main points at the end of class.

In order to demonstrate to students that knowledge transcends the lecture hall, we must encourage this type of critical analysis. By failing to do this, our classrooms remain in a state of stagnancy.

As an aspiring tech entrepreneur, I see great potential in the concept of online learning. The recent rise of MOOCs (Massive Open Online Courses) is certainly changing the educational landscape. Yet, it is only a change in the method of educational delivery. MOOCs are not going to replace the lecture room, but are instead going to co-exist with the lecture model.

Learning is a social process. In order for the lecture to remain relevant, however, it must stimulate the minds of students. While many might see such steps being taken only in the realms of the social sciences and arts, the great theories of science and math were also born out of the basic curiosity of critical thinkers. As Bernard Baruch writes, “millions saw the apple fall, but Newton asked why.”

Empowering students to collectively question the world should be at the forefront of education.

Japreet Lehal is a student at Simon Fraser University Surrey. He writes regularly for The Leader.


Surrey North Delta Leader

Get local stories you won't find anywhere else right to your inbox.
Sign up here

Just Posted

OUR VIEW: Be vigilant when looking for love

Surrey Mounties say they’re seeing increase in sexual assault complaints related to people meeting after using online dating apps

MINTY: It’s never too late to create, as these Surrey seniors show

Pacifica Never Too Late Art Collective members are ‘late bloomers’ with works shown at Newton gallery

North Delta’s Brandon Bassi honoured in throne speech

Former NDSS Huskies captain died in following a car crash in Surrey on May 18, 2019

Surrey Mounties arrest man in Chatr Mobile store robbery in Whalley

Jeremy Morgan, 32, is alleged to have had a loaded gun when he was arrested on Feb. 12

Surrey RCMP recover $80,000 worth of stolen property

Police found the property after executing two search warrants in Newton

Protesters barricade Premier John Horgan’s home ahead of B.C. budget unveiling

Demonstrators from the Extinction Rebellion have blocked the Langford driveway

Kids exposed to household cleaners as newborns more likely to get asthma: B.C. study

Air fresheners, plug-in deodorizers, antimicrobial hand sanitizers and oven cleaners were the worst culprits

Victoria, Abbotsford record biggest jumps in rent prices nationwide: report

Toronto and Vancouver had priciest rentals in Canada

VIDEO: Convoy of forest industry supporters on its way to Victoria

Rally at the B.C. legislature begins with participants setting off from Campbell River

Teen snowmobiler found safe after overnight search in Okanagan

The teen had been missing since just after 6 p.m. on Monday

New highway proposed between Alberta and B.C.

The route would connect Red Deer to Kamloops

Woman arrested in Cariboo after fuel stolen, police car rammed

Suspect wanted for crimes allegedly committed in Kelowna, Salmon Arm and 100 Mile House

No dramatic shifts expected as B.C. government tables new budget today

Finance Minister Carole James has promised to stay the course when she tables the budget in the legislature

Most Read