OUR VIEW: Where there’s smoke, there’s confusion

Research reveals smoke alarms save lives, and yet the courts found it "mere conjecture" that an early warning would have prevented injury.

Surrey firefighters fight a duplex fire.

If you’re in the mood to contemplate perplexing civil court decisions, read our story about a Delta couple renting a home without a smoke alarm.

SEE MORE: Delta tenants burned out in fire lose second round in court against landlord who didn’t install smoke alarms

There’s a late-night fire, which kills the couple’s dog. The tenants sue their landlord, telling a judge they didn’t have time to use fire extinguishers they’d purchased because by the time they were awoken the fire was already too big for them to fight.

The couple claims to have badgered the landlord to install smoke alarms, but he didn’t. The trial judge finds the landlord negligent in not installing and maintaining smoke alarms but dismisses the couple’s claim against the landlord because somehow, it’s “mere conjecture” that an early warning would have prevented their injuries.

The couple then launches an appeal, and the Appeal Court denies their claim, finding “no evidence that a smoke alarm would probably have woken the occupants and allowed them to escape before the fire progressed beyond the smoke stage.”

Meantime, in an apparently parallel universe, a study by Surrey city staff and the University of the Fraser Valley revealed that fire damage is reduced by 19 per cent when a working smoke alarm is present and the death rate per 1,000 fires is 74 per cent greater when a working smoke alarm isn’t present.

It’s a head scratcher, for sure. The research says smoke alarms save lives, but the courts say it’s “mere conjecture” that such an early warning system would have prevented the tenants’ injuries in this court case.


The Now

Just Posted

Air ambulance called to scene after report of shots fired in Abbotsford

Incident Monday afternoon in the area of Ross and Simpson roads

Surrey Mounties investigate drive-by shooting in Fleetwood

It happened Monday afternoon in the 8000-block of 153A Street. Police say no victim has been located.

18-year-old to hospital after shots fired in White Rock

Police investigating early-morning incident

UPDATE: White Rock RCMP unaffected by Surrey’s choice of police force, city says

Mayor Darryl Walker to meet with RCMP Staff Sgt. Daryl Creighton

VIDEO: Marvel Comics’ Stan Lee dies

Marvel co-creator was well-known for making cameo appearances in superhero movies

Calgary 2026 leader expects close vote in Winter Games plebiscite

Residents to choose in a non-binding vote on Tuesday whether they want city to bid on 2026 Olympics

VIDEO: Newcomer kids see first Canadian snowfall

Children arrived in Canada with their mother and two siblings last week from Eritrea

Feds dropped ball with WWI anniversary tributes: historians

Wrote one historian: ‘Other than the Vimy Ridge celebration … I think they have done a very bad job’

Sides ‘far apart’ in Canada Post talks despite mediation, says union

The lack of a breakthrough means rotating strikes will resume Tuesday

Feds’ appeal of solitary confinement decision in B.C. to be heard

Judge ruled in January that indefinite such confinement is unconstitutional, causes permanent harm

Touching note left on Lower Mainland veteran’s windshield

A veteran is hoping the writers of a note know how much he was touched by their kind words.

B.C. health care payroll tax approved, takes effect Jan. 1

Employers calculating cost, including property taxes increases

Nunavut urges new plan to deal with too many polar bears

Territory recommends a proposal that contradicts much of conventional scientific thinking

Most Read