B.C.’s Court of Appeal in Vancouver. (Photo: Tom Zytaruk)

Surrey sex assault conviction overturned, new trial ordered

Appeal court found Surrey judge erred in assessing text messages between the accused and his alleged victim

A new trial has been ordered after B.C.’s Court of Appeal overturned a sexual assault conviction in Surrey.

The accused, identified in court only as R.S.B., had been convicted on Dec. 12, 2017 of one count of sexual assault but acquitted of five other crimes on the same indictment, including assault and uttering a threat to cause death or bodily harm.

The appeal court on Jan. 23 ordered a new trial, finding the Surrey provincial court judge erred in respect to his assessment of text messages sent between the accused and his alleged victim.

Justice Mary Saunders noted credibility “was the central issue at trial.” The Surrey judge found the alleged victim to be a credible witness concerning the conviction that was the subject of the appeal and found the accused’s testimony didn’t raise a reasonable doubt, Saunders said in her oral reasons for judgment.

Saunders said the trial judge rejected his testimony on two “prongs,” namely, his claim he did not go into a room where the sexual assault was alleged to have taken place, and his claim he didn’t have sex with the complainant after late 2015.

READ ALSO: New trials ordered for two accused robbers convicted in Surrey court

READ ALSO: New trial for Surrey man, possessing stolen truck conviction overturned

READ ALSO: Appeal court quashes Surrey drug trafficking convictions, orders new trial

The trial judge found R.S.B.’s denial was inconsistent with text messages he had sent to his alleged victim but were consistent with the complainant’s claim that a sex assault occurred in April 2016.

But the appeal court found the text messages “simply are not inconsistent with the appellant’s evidence as to when the parties last had sexual relations, contrary to the judge’s finding of inconsistency that was one of the bases given for finding the appellant lacked credibility.”

Saunders also found the judge erred in finding that other text messages corroborated the alleged victim’s testimony as to when the sexual assault was alleged to have occurred.

“The erroneous interpretation of those text messages formed part of the judge’s reasoning in assessing the complainant’s credibility,” Saunders said. “I consider that both errors fatally undermine the verdict because they are material to the assessments of credibility.”

Appeal court Justices Gregory Fitch and Bruce Butler concurred.

“I would set aside the conviction and order a new trial,” Saunders decided.



tom.zytaruk@surreynowleader.com

Like us on Facebook Follow us on Instagram and follow Tom on Twitter

Get local stories you won't find anywhere else right to your inbox.
Sign up here

Just Posted

Surrey councillors say halt policing transition as 2,000-plus workers laid off

City of Surrey has reportedly laid off 1,900 part-time auxiliary workers and 140 full-time employees because of the pandemic

‘Shocking decision’: Surrey soccer club won’t offer refunds to 350 teams for cancelled tourney

Registration fees would top $171K for Surrey Mayor’s Cup, called off due to COVID-19

Boundary Bay Airshow latest Delta event cancelled due to COVID-19

Airshow joins the Delta Triathlon, Tour de Delta and North Delta Family Day on list of cancellations

Thousands of ‘PPE’ donated in Surrey, where one care home is ‘preparing for the worst’

SafeCare BC’s Operation Protect drive involves drop-off dates in Guildford

White Rock announces more COVID-19-related changes to parking

Additional, temporary measures about safety, access: mayor

From inside the ER: B.C. doctor tells it like it is from the frontlines of COVID-19

‘Stay home. It’s working,’ says ER doctor in a Q&A discussion, ‘And please don’t worry.’

Businesses advised to prepare for federal, B.C. COVID-19 assistance

Canada Revenue Agency portal expected to open next week

Dogs are property, not kids, B.C. judge tells former couple

Court decision made on competing lawsuits over Zeus and Aurora — a pit bull and pit bull cross

B.C. senior gives blood for 200th time, has ‘saved’ 600 lives

There was no cutting of cake for Harvey Rempel but he’s challenging youth to start donating blood

Trudeau commits $100M to help food banks amid COVID-19 crisis

Funds will help ‘urgent food needs’ for Canadians awaiting federal emergency benefits to kick in

Captain America joins friendly Abbotsford Spider-Man to take down trash

Local garbage crew bringing smiles to city amid pandemic

Couple won’t self-isolate after returning from overseas: Cowichan by-law

New law requires 14 days of self-isolation when returning to Canada

How well can cell phones carry COVID-19? Disinfecting may be wise

‘You want to keep it as clean as you would normally your hands’

3M pushes back on Trump administration call to stop sending N95 masks to Canada

3M says it has already been turning out as many of the N95 masks as possible

Most Read